LOT WISDOM

Buyer’s guide · Official prices, EPA figures, energy prices, and AAA 2026 compact-SUV averages checked Nov. 11, 2026

Hybrid vs Gas vs EV: The Real Five-Year Cost

Gas, hybrid, or electric: which compact SUV actually costs less to own over five years? This page compares a matched Hyundai trio — the 2026 Tucson SE front-wheel drive, the 2026 Tucson Hybrid SE front-wheel drive, and the 2027 Ioniq 5 SE Long Range rear-wheel drive — using official sticker prices, EPA efficiency, current gas and electricity prices, and AAA’s 2026 compact-SUV ownership costs. Hosted by Jack, our AI host.

Watch the YouTube guide

This is general information, not financial, tax, or legal advice, and not a recommendation to buy any vehicle. Prices, rates, insurance, depreciation, taxes, and incentives change, and they vary by where you live and how you drive. These are official starting prices plus destination, not out-the-door prices. Taxes, title, registration, documentation fees, and dealer-added products vary. Confirm the window sticker and your own numbers at the dealership before you sign. No figures on this page were invented. Official prices and EPA figures are from the manufacturer or the government. Calculated bills, gaps, and break-evens are labeled our math. AAA five-year totals are compact-SUV category averages, not a quote for the Tucson or the Ioniq 5.

A fair comparison

No current U.S. compact SUV is sold as the same nameplate in gas, hybrid, and battery-electric form. The closest fair comparison on sale today is one brand, one class, and single-axle drive: front-wheel-drive Tucson and Tucson Hybrid next to a rear-wheel-drive Ioniq 5. All-wheel-drive versions cost more and use more energy, so they are not mixed into the headline table.

The all-new 2027 Tucson is not on sale as of this check. HyundaiUSA says the U.S. launch is early 2027, and there was no official 2027 Tucson pricing sheet on Nov. 11, 2026. This guide keeps the 2026 Tucson as the gas and hybrid example.

The headline electric is the Ioniq 5 SE Long Range, because 318 miles is the fairer range comparison next to a Tucson. The SE Standard Range starts lower but has a 245-mile range; it is shown as a sensitivity, not the headline car.

2026 Tucson SE FWD (gas)2026 Tucson Hybrid SE FWD2027 Ioniq 5 SE Long Range RWD
MSRP$29,700$31,300$37,750
Destination$1,650$1,650$1,650
As delivered (our math)$31,350$32,950$39,400
EPA combined28 mpg (25 city / 33 highway)38 mpg (40 city / 35 highway)114 MPGe (129 city / 100 highway)
Energy use / rangeRegular gasolineRegular gasoline30 kWh / 100 mi · 318-mile range

Sources: Hyundai Motor America 26MY Tucson pricing sheet, July 29, 2026; 27MY Ioniq 5 pricing sheet, Aug. 3, 2026; EPA ids 49453, 51096, and 50645. As-delivered totals are our math (MSRP + official destination). Freight is the same $1,650 on all three, so MSRP gaps and as-delivered gaps match. These are MSRPs, not out-the-door prices; dealer selling prices vary.

What five years actually costs

Fuel is only one line. AAA’s 2026 study also counts depreciation, maintenance, insurance, finance, and license, registration, and taxes, averaged over five years and 75,000 miles. This page uses that horizon, then prices this trio’s energy bills at current EIA and AAA rates.

InputValue used hereSource
Holding period5 yearsAAA Your Driving Costs 2026
Headline miles15,000 a year (75,000 in five years)EPA Fuel Economy Guide and AAA
Second case12,000 a year (60,000 in five years)Shown as a sensitivity
Driving mixEPA combined (55% city / 45% highway)2026 Fuel Economy Guide
Regular gasoline$3.995 / gallonEIA weekly U.S. regular, week of Nov. 9, 2026 (released Nov. 10)
Home electricity18.16¢ / kWhEIA Electric Power Monthly Table 5.3, U.S. residential, August 2026 (prelim.; released Oct. 23)
Public charging$0.421 / kWhAAA U.S. average, Nov. 11, 2026, blended Level 1 + Level 2 + DC fast
Federal new EV / hybrid plug-in credit$0IRS: not available for vehicles acquired after Sept. 30, 2025
Federal home-charger credit (30C)$0 for a new installIRS: property must have been placed in service before July 1, 2026
State or utility incentivesNot in the base caseThey vary; check locally

AAA’s own study used $4.152 / gallon and 18¢ / kWh (12 months ending May 2026). That is why AAA’s fuel dollars differ slightly from the EIA-priced energy bills below. When this page quotes AAA totals, it quotes AAA’s prices. When it quotes this trio’s fuel bill, it uses the EIA and AAA public prices in the table.

Fuel and charging

Formulas, using EPA combined efficiency (our math):

Rounded to the nearest dollar unless the figure is exact or ends in .50.

Vehicle12,000 miles / year5 years at 12,00015,000 miles / year5 years at 15,000
Tucson gas, 28 mpg$1,712$8,561$2,140$10,701
Tucson Hybrid FWD, 38 mpg$1,262$6,308$1,577$7,885
Ioniq 5 Long Range, home 18.16¢ / kWh$654$3,269$817$4,086
Ioniq 5 Long Range, public $0.421 / kWh$1,516$7,578$1,894.50$9,472.50
Ioniq 5 Standard Range, home 18.16¢ / kWh$632$3,160$790$3,950

Five-year energy savings versus the gas Tucson, at these prices (our math):

ComparisonAt 12,000 miles / yearAt 15,000 miles / year
Hybrid vs gas$2,253$2,816
Ioniq 5 Long Range, home vs gas$5,292$6,615
Ioniq 5 Long Range, public vs gas$983$1,228
Ioniq 5 Long Range, home vs hybrid$3,039$3,799

Home charging is where the EV’s fuel advantage is large. On AAA’s blended public-charging average, the long-range Ioniq 5’s five-year energy bill at 15,000 miles ($9,472.50) is only about $1,228 below the gas Tucson — and higher than the hybrid ($7,885).

Sources: EPA combined figures above; EIA weekly U.S. regular $3.995, week of Nov. 9, 2026; EIA residential 18.16¢ / kWh, August 2026; AAA public charging $0.421 / kWh, Nov. 11, 2026. Standard Range electricity use is 29 kWh / 100 mi (EPA id 50646).

Sticker, credit, and depreciation

MSRP gaps, before tax, and the same after adding the shared $1,650 destination (our math):

Do not subtract a $7,500 federal clean-vehicle credit from the Ioniq 5. The IRS says that credit is not available for a vehicle acquired after Sept. 30, 2025. The federal home-charger credit (30C) also does not apply to property placed in service after June 30, 2026. State and utility incentives are not in the base case; they vary, so check locally.

A simple energy-only break-even on the starting-MSRP gap ignores depreciation, insurance, finance, tax, and a home-charger install. It answers only: if the only difference were fuel, how long until the extra sticker is earned back?

UpgradeExtra MSRPEnergy savings at 15,000 miles / yearMiles to break evenYears at 12,000Years at 15,000
Hybrid vs gas$1,600$563 / year42,613 miles3.6 years2.8 years
Ioniq 5 Long Range, home vs gas$8,050$1,323 / year91,271 miles7.6 years6.1 years
Ioniq 5 Standard Range, home vs gas$5,550$1,350 / year61,657 miles5.1 years4.1 years
Ioniq 5 Long Range, public vs gas$8,050$246 / year~328,000 milesFar beyond five years
Ioniq 5 Long Range, home vs hybrid$6,450$760 / year~127,000 miles~10.6 years8.5 years

Break-evens are our math at the energy prices above. The EV’s higher five-year depreciation in AAA’s compact-SUV table is why a fuel-only break-even is not the whole story.

Maintenance and the other lines

These are AAA 2026 compact-SUV averages, not a quote for the Tucson or the Ioniq 5. Annual figures are AAA’s, at 15,000 miles a year. The five-year column is our math (annual × 5).

LineHybridGasElectric
Fuel (AAA prices)$1,731 / year$2,382 / year$771 / year
Maintenance, repair, and tires$1,506 / year$1,954 / year$1,402 / year
Depreciation$3,845 / year$3,568 / year$5,298 / year
Full-coverage insurance$2,294 / year$2,188 / year$2,277 / year
License, registration, taxes$739 / year$631 / year$931 / year
Finance charges$1,087 / year$933 / year$1,208 / year
Total per year$11,201$11,656$11,888
Five-year total (our math)$56,005$58,280$59,440
Cost per mile74.7¢77.7¢79.3¢

Over five years at 15,000 miles, the compact-SUV hybrid costs $2,275 less than gas and $3,435 less than the EV in AAA’s table (our math). The EV wins on fuel ($771 vs $2,382) and wins on maintenance ($1,402 vs $1,954), but it loses more to depreciation ($5,298 vs $3,568) — and that depreciation gap more than eats the fuel savings over five years in this class.

Insurance in this table is close across powertrains. These are category averages, not personal quotes, so this page does not claim EV insurance is always much higher, or that it is identical.

Hyundai’s published warranties, checked Nov. 11, 2026, are 5 years / 60,000 miles new-vehicle limited and 10 years / 100,000 miles powertrain on both the Tucson and the Ioniq 5. The Ioniq 5 battery is 10 years / 100,000 miles, with Hyundai’s stated exclusions. That supports the maintenance discussion; it is coverage, not a cost.

Source: AAA Your Driving Costs 2026, brochure p. 3, compact-SUV bonus analysis; news release dated Sept. 15, 2026. Warranty: HyundaiUSA pages, Nov. 11, 2026.

The five-year totals

AAA’s official compact-SUV five-year totals, at 15,000 miles a year, are hybrid $56,005, gas $58,280, and electric $59,440 (our math: AAA annual × 5). That order is hybrid, then gas, then EV.

The worked estimate below is not an official AAA total for these three Hyundais. It swaps our EIA-priced energy bills (15,000 miles, five years) into AAA’s compact-SUV non-fuel category lines, so the fuel line matches current prices and this trio’s EPA numbers.

AAA non-fuel five-year subtotals at 15,000 miles (our math: (annual − fuel) × 5): gas $46,370; hybrid $47,350; EV $55,585.

Energy (our math, EIA / AAA public)AAA non-fuel (category)Worked five-year estimate
Tucson gas$10,701$46,370$57,071
Tucson Hybrid$7,885$47,350$55,235
Ioniq 5 Long Range, home$4,086$55,585$59,671
Ioniq 5 Long Range, public$9,472.50$55,585$65,057.50

The ranking stays the same as AAA’s official table: hybrid, then gas, then EV over five years at 15,000 miles, unless the EV is charged at home and depreciation on that specific Ioniq 5 is much kinder than AAA’s compact-SUV EV average — which this page has not verified. This guide does not have model-specific five-year residual values for these exact trims.

Who wins for which driver

This is not a ranked “everybody should buy X.” Rerun the math with your miles and your rates.

Electricity and gas prices vary a lot by region. EIA Table 5.6.A, August 2026: U.S. residential 18.16¢ / kWh, New England 28.31¢ / kWh. EIA regular gasoline for the week of Nov. 9, 2026: U.S. $3.995, Gulf Coast $3.481, West Coast $5.110, California $5.562. Use your own rates, not just the national averages.

The five-year checklist

  1. Write down your real miles per year, and your local gas and home-electric rates — not just the national averages.
  2. Compare a fair trio (same class, same drivetrain idea), using EPA combined miles per gallon or kilowatt-hours per 100 miles.
  3. Do not subtract a federal EV credit unless you actually acquired the vehicle on or before Sept. 30, 2025. Source: IRS.
  4. Price energy two ways for the EV: home (or work) vs public charging.
  5. Add the non-fuel piles — especially depreciation — instead of stopping at the fuel savings.
  6. If you want a home Level 2 charger, get a local install quote; the federal charger credit is no longer in play for new installs after June 30, 2026. Source: IRS. This page does not cite a national install price.
  7. Get the out-the-door price, not just MSRP, and make sure destination and dealer add-ons are itemized.

Sources

Checked Nov. 11, 2026. Official manufacturer and government pages are used for prices, fuel economy, and tax-credit status. AAA’s 2026 Your Driving Costs study is used for five-year ownership categories. Those AAA lines are category averages, not quotes for the three Hyundai examples. Calculated figures are labeled our math.